Attempts to clear fluid mechanically from the lungs are generally unnecessary as most fluid will be reabsorbed. Drowning can occur with dry lungs in approximately 10% of cases due to a reflexive, severe laryngospasm that prevents water entry but leads to asphyxia.
Characteristic |
Freshwater Drowning |
Saltwater Drowning |
Water Type |
Freshwater from lakes, rivers, pools |
Saltwater from oceans, seas |
Fluid Movement |
Freshwater is rapidly absorbed into the bloodstream through the alveolar membrane. |
Saltwater is hypertonic and draws fluid from the blood into the alveoli (lungs). |
Effect on Blood Volume |
Leads to haemodilution (dilution of the blood) and potentially hypervolemia. |
Leads to hypovolemia (decrease in blood volume) due to fluid shifting into the lungs. |
Electrolyte Changes |
Can cause dilution of blood electrolytes, leading to hyperkalemia (elevated potassium) and hyponatremia (low sodium). |
Can cause hemoconcentration (increase in red blood cells concentration) and hypernatremia (elevated sodium). |
Impact on Lungs |
Water is absorbed into the blood, causing haemolysis (red blood cell destruction) and potential pulmonary edema (fluid overload in the lungs). |
Fluid is drawn into the lungs, leading to significant pulmonary edema and impaired oxygen exchange. |
Cardiac Effects |
Electrolyte imbalances, particularly hyperkalemia, can lead to dangerous cardiac arrhythmias and sudden cardiac arrest. |
Pulmonary edema and hypoxemia (low blood oxygen levels) can lead to hypoxia-induced arrhythmias and cardiac arrest. |
Pulmonary Edema |
Less common but can occur due to water absorption and damage to lung tissue. |
Common, as saltwater draws more fluid into the alveoli, causing severe pulmonary edema. |
Treatment Considerations |
Rapid correction of electrolyte imbalances and respiratory support are critical. |
Management of pulmonary edema and prevention of hypovolemia are important. |